Monday, August 18, 2008

Anti-contraception regulations foster dishonesty

There is no author name for this article, Anti-contraception regulations foster dishonesty, so I am not sure who wrote this. Mr. Winkler was kind enough to refrain from political attacks and his personal agenda for this week - thank you. My critique of yet another very opinionated article from GBCS follows but I want to add first that while I am not a fan of abortion, I have no issues with contraception.

  1. Not saying people shouldn't get excited when things are leaked out, but every page of the document in questions states the following at the bottom: "This is a confidential, deliberative, pre-decisional document and does not necessarily reflect current policy efforts or plans. For official use only" and says in bold at the top of the page "Draft". Might all this excitement be a bit premature...unless it has more political motivation than actual concern? Can you imagine if every draft document in process today, public and private, were leaked out to the public?
  2. Where is a link to the drafted legislation in question? Even going to the link for "additional information" doesn't provide it. Is this more of the "you're too dumb and lazy to read it for yourself, so just do what we tell you"? For those interested in the facts, here is the original draft in question (note, since it is not officially released even for internal government review I could not find an "official government" site hosting the document): http://www.rhrealitycheck.org/emailphotos/pdf/HHS-45-CFR.pdf
  3. It should also be noted that the medical community has blurred the lines of abortion and contraception by pointing out high doses of contraception medication will function as the "morning after pill". Interesting that this ongoing debate is forgotten amongst the ridicule of the administration confusing contraception and abortion.
  4. There may be situations where a woman's health is jeopardized as GBCS director is quoted, but why the general statements of fear - how about a few specific examples of how this draft would put a woman's health at risk?
  5. Another GBCS director is quoted as saying, the draft is "intended to restrict access of women to service". To me, that seems like a stretch and just maybe a bit of fear provoking rhetoric? I mean really, I can't imagine the Bush administration holding a special meeting to say..."OK folks, these American women are getting way too many services - time to cut them back". But maybe, just maybe, there is a new GBCS crystal ball that the UMC members have funded at their disposal?
  6. The same GBCS director goes on to say it would "limit the services provided based on ideological positions rather than sound health care". Now let's keep in mind, the opening sentence providing a background for the draft, "Religious liberty and freedom of conscience have long been protected in the Constitution and laws of the United States." So this director of a Christian organization has reduced religious liberty to ideological positions. Shall we rename Faith Based organizations to Ideologically Based? Seems to undermine almost all arguments based on a religious belief - especially including Christians when this commentary comes from an official of a Christian organization.
  7. Again, not saying it is perfect, but the draft only speaks to those organizations receiving DHHS funds. I think this is an important distinction.
There are other annoyances of bias and contradiction but it seems as though this short article could be fodder that would take too much of my time now (like "what's up with the title, never did get the 'foster dishonesty' part"). Remember, unlike the GBCS folks who receive a salary from UMC members, I write this on my own time and money. Bottom line: if for some reason the need is felt to respond, how about responding with some suggestions. It seems to me the intent is to protect the shrinking rights of individuals with morally based contradictions to tasks they may be asked to perform (in organizations that receive DHHS funding). So if the fear is that, as written in internal draft form, that it doesn't differentiate contraception from abortion, then suggest an alternate wording (keeping in mind that it has already been blurred with "emergency contraception").

By the way, a fairly short article with a similar distaste for this draft legislation can be found here and is full of information - sans personal bias and statements on how an individual should react (and sans original legislation draft text unfortunately). My point in sharing this one article, as I am sure there are many others, is that it does not appear to have an agenda as the one from GBCS clearly does. The host of that article just presents the information with their analysis - I can use that article to form my own views on the topics. I don't need my apportionment money going to pay GBCS to tell me how to think!

Respectfully,
David Mentzer

Tuesday, August 5, 2008

Perception vs Truth

In his 1 August 08 article entitled "Perception vs Truth", Mr. Winkler makes many assertions of fact himself while condemning some unnamed group of spreading information as fact that isn't true about Senator Obama. He goes on to compare this misinformation attempt to that of Nazi Germany. First, that seems a bit of a stretch to make such a comparison...and then goes on to a modern day comparison to that of Mugabe and his murderous run for president. A reader has to ask - since when is Mr. Winkler the expert and defacto knowledge base for Senator Obama's life history? Was his source the New York Times by chance...on no, it is from the "stack of books" on his bedside table.

He continues on to somehow in his writing to lead the reader to believe that VP Cheney is somehow similar to Mugabe while making "insane threats to bomb Iran". So it would now seem that not only is Winkler pushing it to make another comparison, but is also an expert in global and national security - otherwise he would not be so quick to add commentary or subjective comments such as "insane".

And then, much like Obama did with his "bible...and gun hugging...scared of people who don't look like themselves" comment about regular ole' Americans, Winkler then pushes the idea that the typical Christian has as much biblical knowledge as those folks embarrassed on the Leno show.

Put it all together, and the reader is left to believe that they are too ignorant of current topics or even their own religion to know better...so listen to Winkler - he knows all!